5 min read

What an Alumni Director Taught Me About All Donors

I have worked in fundraising for over thirty years, but never in education. I focused on social and human services. Still, I always envied fundraisers who had alumni to work with. To me, it seemed like shooting fish in a barrel. And in some instances, it is, especially for a college. There are alumni who understand the importance of giving and have the resources early in their careers. But what about older alumni, especially those who might not have had a perfect college experience?

Now, don’t get me wrong. In my four years at Rhodes College, where my life changed for the better academically, it just wasn’t socially what I had dreamed of. So I never supported the college financially.

Enter the college’s alumni director. Tracy happened to be a classmate who knew about my experience and had stayed in touch over the years. We were Facebook friends and so on. Then she started inviting me to lunch whenever she was in New York. Now, as a fundraiser, I know what “lunch” means. But Tracy never asked me for a gift. Instead, she talked to me about the college and described how it had changed and how growth had softened many of the issues I had faced. This went on for several years. Then one December I decided to make a small gift. All on my own. Kind of.

A few years earlier, the college had created an alumni board. This group came up in our conversations. I didn’t think much of it. But at a lunch a few years ago, she mentioned that having a fundraiser on the council would be helpful to her. The next time we chatted, she asked if I would be willing to serve on that board. It would mean being on campus twice a year and supporting the college here in New York.

Now let’s make something clear. I had attended my class reunions and helped current students in small ways when asked. Since our first lunch, I had become a moderately active alum. I thought about her offer and decided to join the alumni board. It was a three-year commitment. By the end of those three years, I had visited the college six times and hosted several alumni events in New York City. My husband and I also had to update our will, and I decided to include a legacy gift to Rhodes. My yearly gift is still small, but it is consistent. So why am I telling you all of this?

Relationships are complicated, and you have to take the long view. Tracy knew I would not be able to make a large gift, but she also knew that if she got me involved, I would bring valuable resources to the college. Not just because I am a fundraiser, but because I would help her carry out alumni projects in New York, put my name on the reunion request, and make the college part of my volunteer life again.

To me, that is the key to strong donor and prospect relationships. We have to think long term, not just this year’s goal. If your pipeline is filled with long-term prospects, some will come due. You will have an active pipeline of not just donors but also people who support your cause.

Admittedly, alumni outreach can be a bit easier, and the fact that Tracy was a classmate helped. But since that first lunch, I have watched her use this same relationship-building technique with many other alumni. One caution, though. You have to be authentic. You cannot treat this as a transactional act. The donor or prospect will sense it, and you will hit a wall.

So how does this work if you do not have alumni? You have the same raw material. Every organization has people who have been showing up for years without anyone paying much attention to them.

Start by picking two or three. Not twenty. Two or three. The donor who has given $250 every December for eleven years. The volunteer who has never made a gift but has never missed a shift. The board member’s friend who comes to every event and has never been asked for anything.

Show up without an ask. Coffee, a site visit, a phone call, whatever fits. No case statement, no pledge card. If you ask on the first visit, you have told them exactly what the relationship is.

Tell them what has changed. This is the part most of us get wrong. We send the newsletter and assume it landed. Tracy never argued with my version of Rhodes; she just kept describing the place as it is now. A food bank that moved from boxes to a client choice pantry has that same story. So does a shelter that added case management. Most of your long-time supporters are still picturing the organization they met years ago.

Then ask for something other than money. Chair a committee. Host a house party. Sign the year-end letter. Make one introduction. Sit on an advisory group you may have to create. It does not matter much what the ask is. What matters is that saying yes gives them a stake in the work.

None of this is fast. It took Tracy years to get a small gift out of me and a few more to get a legacy gift. But she was never really working on the gift. She was working on the relationship, and the gift followed.

And here is what I keep coming back to. I spent thirty years envying the fundraisers who had alumni, when what actually moved me had almost nothing to do with being an alum. It was one person who kept showing up and never made me feel like a transaction. You do not need a graduating class for that. You just need to decide who is worth the long view.

Ready to strengthen your fundraising?

Let’s discuss how we can help your organization build sustainable philanthropic support.